Controversy Erupts Over Baby DONT Cry’s “Inappropriate” Debut Concept Produced by (G)I-DLE’s Soyeon

Key Takeaways:

• PNation’s new girl group Baby DONT Cry faces backlash over debut teaser

• Condom-inspired candy packaging in MV teaser sparks controversy

• 3 of 4 members are minors, raising concerns about sexualized concept

• (G)I-DLE’s Soyeon’s involvement as producer draws mixed reactions

• Song title “F Girl” criticized as inappropriate for young members

Breaking Down the Controversy

PNation’s upcoming girl group Baby DONT Cry – produced by (G)I-DLE’s Soyeon – has ignited a firestorm of criticism just days before their debut. The group’s first teaser for single “F Girl” has drawn intense scrutiny for its questionable creative direction.

What Sparked the Backlash?

The June 20 teaser shows:

• A member approaching a store clerk

• Placing a condom-shaped candy packet on the counter

• The clerk’s disapproving look before she eats the candy

While some praised the bold, cheeky concept, many fans expressed discomfort given:

• 3/4 members are underage (exact ages unconfirmed)

• The “F Girl” title’s potential connotations

• Concerns about sexualizing young idols

Soyeon’s Role in the Controversy

As the group’s primary producer, (G)I-DLE’s leader Soyeon has faced criticism, though fans defend her:

• Likely only involved in music production, not visuals

• PNation (PSY’s label) ultimately controls creative direction

• Previous work with minors (like in My Teenage Girl) was age-appropriate

Fan Reactions:

“Soyeon makes mature concepts work for adults, but this feels wrong for kids”
“PSY’s team should know better than to give minors this concept”
“Why debut minors with ‘F Girl’ as the title track?”

Industry Concerns About Minor Idols

This incident highlights ongoing debates about:

• Age-appropriate concepts for young K-pop stars

• Companies sexualizing minors for shock value

• Producer responsibility when working with underage artists

Recent similar controversies include:

• NewJeans’ “Cookie” lyrics debate

• IVE’s “Kitsch” schoolgirl imagery

• Lesserafim’s “Fearless” choreography critiques

What Happens Next?

With debut imminent, PNation must decide whether to:

1. Proceed as planned and risk continued backlash

2. Edit controversial elements from the MV

3. Delay debut to reconsider concept

K-netizens are demanding:

• An apology from PNation

• Revised concept respecting members’ ages

• Clear explanation of Soyeon’s actual involvement